Day 8 of the Diddy Trial: Special Agent Gerard Gannon’s Testimony Centers on Seized Items

As Sean “Diddy” Combs‘ publicized trial approaches its second week, Special Agent Gerard Gannon testifies and continues his appearance on the witness stand, enthralled with fascination by his graphic recitation of the raid on Combs‘ Miami mansion. The day was marked by a recitation of bizarre and incriminating material pulled from bedrooms in the sprawling mansion, as Gannon’s testimony drew a more graphic picture of what officials encountered.

The Closet Search: Shoes, Drugs, and Gadgets

During his testimony, Gannon unveiled the search of a master closet that yielded some crucial pieces of evidence. Among them were a red pump high-heeled shoe and a Balenciaga boot containing several cell phones. They also found a Gucci bag that contained a white powdery substance which, upon testing, tested positive for cocaine and ketamine. The same pouch held a collection of various packets of colored pills, some bearing a Tesla logo. They were discovered to contain MDMA and Xanax.

The discovery of a piece of wood addressed “Puffy” raised more eyebrows. Inside was a crystal rock-like substance that Gannon said tested positive for a hallucinogenic substance. Other pills found in the master bathroom and closet contained the active ingredient found in magic mushrooms. Together, the items represent a stash of controlled substances involving multiple drug categories.

However, it should be noted that Diddy is not being directly charged with drug trafficking or drug possession.

Weapon Discovery and Defense Counterpoints

Attention centered on the guest house on the Miami property where a .45 caliber pistol was found inside a red suitcase at the entrance to a guard shack. Photographs submitted to the courtroom also included a magazine and a bag of bullets. These discoveries added to the growing list of weapons seized from the property.

But when pressed by defense attorney Teny Geragos during cross-examination, Special Agent Gerard Gannon acknowledged several of the guns found were taped up, unloaded, and even inoperative. He also agreed that guns with no serial number are not necessarily untraceable with other forensic methods like fingerprints, DNA, and fiber analysis.

This argument emphasized the defense’s general approach: to minimize the perceived illegality or threat of the weapons cache. Their train of thought suggested the prosecution was presenting the guns in a worse light than necessary.

Items of a Different Nature

Furthermore, legal proceedings also entailed dealing with the revelation of a large bin discovered in a hallway closet. It contained 25 bottles of baby oil, 31 Astroglide lubricant bottles, and one rubber duck. A photograph of the closet contents was submitted into evidence and introduced into court, although no description of the items was given initially. The defense never made a contention regarding these items, and their relevance is still unclear.

The Psychology of Abuse: Dawn Hughes Takes the Stand

Following Gannon’s testimony, the prosecution introduced Dawn Hughes, a clinical and forensic psychologist who is an expert in high-profile abuse cases. Hughes has testified as an expert witness for the trials of Keith Raniere, R. Kelly, and the Depp-Heard defamation trial.

Dressed in a cream-colored suit, Hughes shed light on the psychology of victims of abuse, particularly those in long-term relationships with abusers. Her words, though not specifically aimed at Combs’ former girlfriend Cassie Ventura, laid the basis for addressing the defense’s contention that victims can escape abusive relationships.

Hughes has named some of the things that make it hard for a victim to leave an abusive relationship: control over emotions, psychological dependence, and financial control. These, Hughes has stated, too often result in victims being silent and unable to leave even when abuse persists.

Hughes appeared to agree with Combs’ defense that she doesn’t have this level of intimate knowledge and hasn’t done an evaluation of the alleged abusers and victims, because the witness wasn’t asked to do so. Earlier during direct examination, prosecutors anticipated this line of questioning and asked Hughes why she hadn’t interviewed the defendant or witnesses here. Hughes told the court she wasn’t legally allowed to do so.

The forensic psychologist testifying for the government has never before appeared for a criminal defendant, she said.

Defense attorney Jonathan Bach asked Hughes if she’s ever represented anyone accused of a sex crime. She said she has not. “That’s correct, I don’t evaluate offenders,” Hughes said. Bach also asked Hughes if she is making $600 an hour for her work with prosecutors, which she confirmed. Moments later, under a prosecutor’s questioning, Hughes recalled that she had been hired once before by defense lawyers to evaluate a woman who shot her abusive husband. However, the psychologist said she didn’t end up on the witness stand in that matter.

Her testimony will bolster the prosecution’s overall thesis that emotional and psychological barriers instead of personal choice can explain why some individuals remain in harmful situations.

Another Former Assistant Testifies

Combs’ former assistant, George Kaplan, claims Combs regularly threatened to fire him, with the rapper saying he only wanted the best employees possible, sometimes in a motivational tone, sometimes in an angry tone. Combs also had very exact demands that needed to be met when traveling, such as filling out a list of toiletries that needed to be packed for overnight, Kaplan said. Kaplan was also required to unpack the toiletries and arrange them so they were all facing forward, which would regularly take 30 minutes, the witness said.

Kaplan testified that one of his duties was to clean hotel rooms for Combs, saying that photos of checked-out mess could be embarrassing and sold to tabloids. The former assistant said the rooms would often be littered with liquor bottles and baby oil after Combs stayed in them, and on one occasion, he found white powder near a sink. The witness also said that packing Combs’ medicine bag was always a lengthy challenge as various pills, including Advil, Tylenol, and ketamine, always needed to be included. Kaplan recalled once accepting a delivery of MDMA for Combs in Miami.

Looking Ahead

The jury was excused for the day, and the court will resume tomorrow with continued questioning of George Kaplan. A total of five witnesses will be called, including Scott Mescudi, the rap star known as Kid Cudi. His testimony is hoped to bring a new turn to the unfolding situation, but its nature is only speculative.